Tag: project fi

  • AOL/Verizon – a new world order in digital advertising

    AOL/Verizon – a new world order in digital advertising

    In the last 3 weeks… Google launched Project Fi, Facebook released Instant Articles and an AOL and Verizon merger was announced. Though different on face value, these latest ventures in the Telecommunications, Media and Technology industries represent a new wave of integration between distribution, advertising and content.

     

    Over the past decade internet advertising has been at an inflection point with (ever) increasing ad inventory and commoditised rates for undifferentiated spots. The best response is one that provides better ad placement, measurement and well… better advertising. A new world order.

    The transition of the advertising locus: Desktop, Mobile Device, User

    Desktop advertising has changed with the use of cookies which make tracking easy. Ad networks (like those that AOL own) set a cookie in the browser of the desktop computer that collects the browsing history of the person(s) who use the computer. This has advanced to the point of creating very precise profiles based on a mix of browsing history and offline data (e.g. other point of sale histories, loyalty data). Advertisers can reach people based on their profiles through automated advertising exchanges that use auction pricing and serve up ads in real-time. This enables advertisers to collect almost real-time campaign feedback, allowing for rapid iteration of the campaign – this is called ‘Programmatic advertising’.

    But programmatic advertising is not perfect. It is questionable how well it works in practice and it is particularly difficult to rely on in a Mobile environment where many apps don’t share cookies (how to build a profile?). For mobile to work effectively it needs a unique identifier. 5 years ago it was thought phone unique identifiers could be used but it turned out to be a privacy disaster and Apple and Google banned UDIDs offering IDs that could be reset by users.

    The reality is that the focus of tracking and measurement for advertising is actually not a desktop computer nor a mobile device but a user. Someone who uses multiple devices – and Facebook, Google and AOL/Verizon know it.

    What does this all mean?

    Facebook Instant Articles and Google’s Project Fi

    Facebook has a lot of information about you (e.g. name, birthday, history, address, friends, likes) and what you do on your different devices. With the power of this knowledge it prefers to advertise (profitably) off its own platform. This is very much the impetus behind the release of Instant Articles which is removing the publisher (large news houses) from monetising on their sites (with poorer targeting) and bringing their content to a highly targeted and measured environment.

    The same can be said for Google. Though different to Facebook (perhaps not as successful at Social), Google has maintains IDs across all its properties which do a very good job at ensuring users are logged in all the time. Project Fi as addition allows Google to begin to collect network data about users allowing for offline and unique identifiers on location and habits. Like Facebook – Google prefers to monetise on its on platform and Fi could be its most targeted and measurable offering yet.

    Whilst Facebook and Google have 3rd party advertising offerings they are primarily focused on their own sites. There are a number of fragmented 3rd-party advertisers and ad-tech (e.g. Buddy, Wildfire, Admob, Quattro etc.) but there may now be a very dominant player for advertising on the ‘rest of the web’ in AOL/Verizon.

     

    AOL/Verizon

    A merger like this would have seemed unusual in the TMT industry 10 years ago when core competency mattered, companies stuck to their swim lanes and ‘eco-system’ was a buzz word (still is?). But in this day in age it has logic – at its core AOL has a large ad network and owns content from ~300 sites including Huffpost and Techcrunch. Advertising in a mobile age has been hard given that tracking and measurement is unable to be as specific as Facebook or Google putting a cap on potential earnings. Verizon is able to solve this problem.

    As paid service Verizon knows a lot of personal information including credit history and social security and as a Telco it knows location – which is useful for serving and tracking effectiveness of advertising. It doesn’t need a cookie identifier to target users as it is an ISP which can set up a ‘super cookie’ to track everything users do online. AOL provides the technology to target individuals instead of content, and Verizon the ability to track those individuals.

    A new world order

    Describing these three ventures is like looking at the new world order for internet advertising. One that does not include traditional publishers (be that print or TV). Its possible that most pblishers will be increasingly reliant on programmatic offerings that value the sites ability to attract a specific type of user (because of the content) that and advertiser has bid on. This is a fast route to a very miserly existence.

  • Project Fi: Just another MVNO?

    Project Fi: Just another MVNO?

    This week Google announced the launch of Project Fi. I have written about Google’s plans to launch as a mobile virtual network operator (MVNO) and the implications for Australia – this is the realisation (v.1) of that concept. Google’s description gives some clues into their strategy centred around their nexus hardware offering, android software and partnerships with MNOs to change the connectivity experience:

    ‘That’s why today we’re introducing Project Fi, a program to explore this opportunity by introducing new ideas through a fast and easy wireless experience. Similar to our Nexus hardware program, Project Fi enables us to work in close partnership with leading carriers, hardware makers, and all of you to push the boundaries of what’s possible. By designing across hardware, software and connectivity, we can more fully explore new ways for people to connect and communicate.’

    What is the offering?

    The Project Fi value proposition has some interesting features:

    • Automatic transfer between the T-mobile, Sprint networks and over a million hotspots
    • Simplified pricing: $20 for service, $10 for every GB of data – data is prepaid and unused data rolls over to the following month
    • A cloud-based phone number that enables talk and text from any laptop, tablet or phone

    This last feature is a reincarnation of ‘Google Voice’. Voice from the beginning has been a cloud-based phone number that works across devices. Paradoxically the worst part of Google Voice has been its poor integration with your actual mobile phone; the latter has always been developed with the assumption that a phone number and an actual phone are for all intents and purposes the same thing. Project Fi explicitly unbundles them.

    How is it different from other MVNOs?

    MVNOs exist because the mobile network operators (MNOs), whose networks MVNOs sit over are unable to reach profitable market segments the MNO cannot. While it is the same as other MVNOs in this respect, in other ways it is very different.

    1. Unbundling device from carrier: As with Google Voice which is unbundling the phone from the phone number, Project Fi is unbundling the device from the carrier. The ‘automatic transfer’ makes T-Mobile, Sprint and Wi-Fi mere implementation details which are hidden from the user. In addition, Project Fi users (at the moment) can only connect through a Nexus phone seemingly allowing Google to control the connectivity experience and the preference between WiFi/Network. This, of course, makes connectivity a commodity – literally a ‘dumb pipe’.
    2. Google is a media company: Extending Project Fi further there are other differentiating features. Google clearly wants to incentivise usage of Google’s services and thereby capture more information about its users, improving its algorithm. One could see Google offering free data for streaming on ‘Google Play’ or bundling other Google services like Google cloud or Nest. The more people it connects to the internet (take note, voice is less important here), the better. Simply… other MVNOs are not as interested user’s data as they don’t sell advertising.

    How is it similar?

    Despite these differences there are at least two main similarities which are also limitations of MVNOs:

    1. Pricing: Project Fi is not that much cheaper than other plans. A comparison of similar plans shows that if you use a lot of data you typically pay significantly more than the major carriers and with a number of conditions. The reason is that MNVOs are dependent on the MNOs they operate on and the MNO has little interest in allowing an MVNO to undercut it on price.
    2. Network Coverage: MVNOs are only as good as the networks they are on. Project Fi runs on T-mobile and Sprint which are the smallest of the US carriers and despite the alternating technology coverage is still likely to be limited.

    Will it succeed?

    I’m sceptical about Project Fi having a meaningful impact on the US or global market in the near term – I don’t think Australia is a priority market (high iPhone penetration a major barrier). MNOs have big budgets for advertising and retail distribution which is not Google’s competency. This may be why the launch has received little fanfare from Google and is also called ‘Project’. I am more interested in their Fibre offering or if they were to buy T-mobile as these strategies indicate real ‘skin in the communications game’.