Blog

  • Why the best innovation strategy may be to build and buy

    Why the best innovation strategy may be to build and buy

    To build or to buy (or partner)? Companies faced with the proposition of expanding their existing business model through innovation are often faced with these choices. Increasingly though, companies should consider building and buying simultaneously as a strategic choice in its own right.

    There are different ways to categorise innovation. I like Doblin’s ten types of innovation which looks at innovation on the configuration of the business (e.g how it makes money, the network, structure and process), the offering (e.g the product and product system) and the experience (e.g service, channel, brand, customer engagement). Large companies wanting to innovate often look at enhancing all or some of these levers in an effort to extend their products and services, defend their position in a market or indeed create new markets.

    Much has been written about large corporations flocking to Silicon Valley to find and acquire these innovations. In recent times, venture capital firms like Sequoia, have jumped on this trend adding new roles to their firms whose job it is to match start ups to Fortune 500 companies. These VCs are interested in these acquisitions as much as a lucrative IPO, as it can justify paying large multiples over the current valuation of the start up. For the company buying the start up they are hoping that integration into the existing business will justify the amount they pay. Given the high, very lofty valuations of these start ups (many of the high profile ones are greater than $1bn), integration is extremely important, which history shows has had varying levels of success.

    But what are they actually buying and could they make it themselves? Take an example like Whatsapp? purchased by Facebook for US$19bn. It gives Facebook more presence in mobile, a large user base (arguably largely overlapping with their current member base), access to teams, intellectual property and a new product line in text messaging. Whilst users can be difficult to obtain particularly if they are ‘sticky’ on an existing platform, I believe Facebook could have built its own Whatsapp? team, intellectual property and product line in text messaging, tested it, learnt from it and then acquired (if the build was not successful or to bolster their homemade offering).

    Why does this matter? Many innovation strategies go to a ‘buy’ decision too soon, which can lead to corporations paying too much for a failed integration. With access to cloud technology, platforms and web channels many companies could build (the product line, intellectual property and teams which make up innovation of their business model) or at least build in parallel to buying the target. The knowledge gained in researching the buy target whilst simultaneously building a similar innovation from scratch could be shared to better understand the market, user experience, scalability options and importantly the integration points to the main business…not to mention a better valuation of the target. Large corporations often pay consultants to provide an opinion of these valuation factors for a price, however I would argue that this is not the same as building, testing and learning for yourself.

    So next time a ‘build or buy’ decision arises, consider a ‘build and buy’ strategy…If at the end of the day you acquire the target, the experience of building it in parallel may at the very least save a few hundred million dollars off a multi-billion dollar corporate shopping docket… and at the same time bring you closer to a successful integration of innovation.

  • Start up mentality will ‘change the game’ for larger corporations’ strategic projects

    Start up mentality will ‘change the game’ for larger corporations’ strategic projects

    We have seen it countless times – the team that looks like it will win the championship at the start of the season but ends up failing to reach the finals or, worse yet, with the wooden spoon. But what if you could test out that team before the start of the season? Try a few different combinations? Make some trades based on what you learn? One of the most common criticisms of strategy is that ‘it all looks great on paper but will not succeed in execution’. As an advisor I have witnessed this from a few angles – developing a strategy with an organisation, helping to implement that strategy or even implementing a strategy developed by others. Regardless of how ‘good it looks on paper’, in all cases the success of the strategy is always leveled at the result of the implementation. In fact, as Roger Martin argues, without great execution you don’t really have a strategy at all.

    There are many examples of strategies which have been implemented successfully with careful and calculated planning in all industries, and specifically in TMT. Look at Apple’s ‘I-Strategy‘ (IPod, IPad, IPhone, ITunes) which was (is) a vision executed to near perfection. This took multiple years with large programs of work to implement but probably started as a strategy document (email?) outlining Apple’s choice to venture into portable entertainment and content. For each example of an Apple there are myriad examples of failed implementations, ‘money sinks’ and attractive documents sitting on the CXO’s shelf.

    A different way to look at strategy and its successful implementation is through the eyes of the start up – the lean start up. By this I mean the dorm room dwelling, idea-rich, resource-poor entrepreneurs who are fueled by passion and who access the skills and expertise of not-for-profits (NFPs), friends or even family. This is not a brand new concept however my experiences in both a lean start up and a corporate environment have uncovered some principles which if employed by more mature less agile organisations could change the game for their strategy implementations:

    1) Don’t guess, test your choices in market: With often just a bit more than a hunch that a growing profitable market exists start-ups, particularly those that are digitally-based, use customer feedback to test the choices they make (where they play, how they win). A/B testing (this button or that button) on app or web functionality is very common in these organisations and similar approaches can be applied to a corporate or business unit strategy. Research you perform on the strategic plan will get you to a point but building a beta version of a new product in a new market and recieving live feedback, will confirm or even change the shape of your choice – in most cases for the better.

    2) Speed to market can save money and improve the likelihood of a better, quick implementation result: Start-ups spend less time analysing and more time testing. They see a potential gap and seize the opportunity, learning as they go. Larger organisations can get bogged down in ‘analysis paralysis’ and indecision, which is as much about company cultural as it is about strategy execution. The point here though is that there is a trade off that is often overlooked – spend a year developing and analysing a choice or go to market in 10 weeks and learn from the result. Both options may cost the same but the latter will be better placed to succeed in implementation with the bare bones of the strategy (new product, business) in place.

    3) Minimum Viable Product first, scale second and perfect the idea third: Speed to market means that ‘Minimum Viable Product‘ (the bare bones of the concept or business) is the goal. If a new product or a new business unit in a new market was your choice – design for the basic experience you want to create with your customer but use ‘sticky tape’ for the operating model. Once comfortable with testing and learning, look to drive scale and optimise around the concept. Few start ups have fully automated processes, a CRM, integration into core systems and an HR team in the MInimum Viable Product stage. This will enable you to fail fast and cheaply but also to identify the break points in the construct as your concept achieves scale.

    4) Be prepared to fail fast and learn: Start-ups fail. In fact there is a founders dinner held in San Francisco where you cannot attend unless you have failed at least once. Strategic choices can also be ‘failures’ when they are poorly implemented or not implemented at all. Exiting a concept that you know will not work because you have tested it in market or with users is likely to be less expensive and better at informing the ‘right’ strategic decision than our analysis paralysis example. Key here is failing and learning – informs better decision making.

    5) Encourage low cost, cross-functional collaboration: Larger corporations are usually not as resource constrained as a start up, however they are in many cases not as resourceful. Implementing a strategy can be made difficult with functional silos, company fiefdoms, wars on budgets and an inability to obtain the right skills to implement a strategy (part of the reason I have a job). Start ups use what they have at their disposal – they collaborate with NFPs, they use cloud-based tools like hangouts, google drive/docs and access the shared economy to support their business needs. Larger corporations can borrow this resourcefulness pulling together cross-functional expertise in collaborative, low-cost shared environments to breathe life into implementing their ‘minimum viable product’ choice.

    6) Incentivise through ownership: With risk comes reward and this could not be more evident than in the world of start ups. For the ones that succeed like $19bn buyout of Whatsapp? or the ones that laugh at $3bn buyout offers like Snapchat, the rewards are huge but these companies start out as a founder putting up their savings to kick start an idea. One of the main reasons strategies fail in a corporate world is that people are often not incentivised on the success of implementation. Even if they are, in large corporations it is rarely to the extent that an employee would be forced to make the kinds of decisions a founder has to. If greater than half your salary was tied to implementation targets with upside on success, I imagine failure would be fast…but success would be sweet.

    Is undertaking any of the above a ‘silver bullet’ of successful implementation? To be clear, there is no substitute for informed and iterative decision making about ‘where to play and how to win’ choices your company makes. However through the lens of a start-up, the more time and money spent on analysis paralysis or perfecting a concept before going to market and testing and learning – the more likely your strategy will just ‘look good on paper’.

     

  • Australian digital entrepreneurs are alive… But are they well?

    Australian digital entrepreneurs are alive… But are they well?

    At the end of 2013 I was lucky enough to attend an ‘Angel Dinner’ put on by Innovation Bay at a restaurant in Sydney’s inner-city ‘heart of hip’, Surry Hills. The premise of the event is that entrepreneurs, young and old, have a chance to pitch to a ‘community’ of investors and interested types (TMT strategy consultants included) in a Dragon’s Den format. Innovation Bay supports the pitch night by providing a platform where 10+ entrepreneurs can spruik their ideas with a short video. Attendees vote for their favorite and four entrepreneurs attend the dinner.

    The crowd mingled over cocktails and nibbles then sat down to a communal (social?) meal to hear the pitches one after another and vote with Monopoly money on which they would place their bets. Whilst Monopoly money was used as a proxy on the night, there were legitimate angels in the crowd who no doubt had their eye on a potential investment. The four on show were:

    – Drawboard started by an ex-Deloitte consultant Alister Michener who had identified with his co-founder Mat Barnes a growing need for annotating PDFs in the engineering industry. He confessed he actually used it on an engagement with a client who was so impressed they bought licenses from him. This spurred him into commericalising the product further.

    – Vinus whose founder, Alex Martel an ex-Deloitte consultant, implored the group to take a photo of the wine and watch his wine identifier app match the wine and suggest new wines to try and buy. A great concept except that the operating model requires manual matching performed offshore of labels to wines. He may have required extra staff to cope with the volume of match requests at the dinner.

    – Expert360 which excited me the most in terms of its applicability to the open talent economy and disruption in the consulting/expert advice services industry. Started by two Bain alum Emily Yue and Bridgette Loudon the company aims to be a digital funnel for demand in higher value technical expertise. I caught up with Emily earlier this year who said expansion plans were underway after the start up received a nice $1m injection for their round. Definitely one to watch.

    – Lawpath a new attorney-matching service which uses a matching algorithm to take a legal question and match it to an appropriate attorney. A client then has a 30 min conversation with the attorney. If the question is not solved users get 10 to 20% off the legal fees of the attorney. The model then charges $29 per contact – the attraction for the attorney is a potential client lead. The model, like expert360 and other service platforms, relies on the ability to match demand to supply providing unique customer experience and integration into supplier channels. Talking to a few of the angels at my dinner table, the feeling was that Lawpath CEO Paul Lupson had a winner with his concept – in so much that it had the potential to disrupt the legal market with the matching algorithm a key differentiator.

    I left the night with a sense of excitement that this community is still thriving in Sydney only to be further reminded of this ground swell as I walked past Telstra’s Muru-D complex on Oxford St on my way home. Whilst each of the four entrepreneurs expressed desire for local funding and support they all professed plans to seek offshore funding and scale in overseas markets, namely the US or Asia.

    It seems that the number of start ups has grown but capital investment has not kept pace. I believe a number of factors play into this including the risk appetite of investors, Australian property prices absorbing consumer capital, few tax breaks for start-ups, share option tax rules, investment in property seen as a no-brainer and ‘living the Australian Dream’, general lack of understanding of digital business in Australia (how does Facebook make money?) and no public champion or major public agenda for digital business by the Australian government.

    Talk to almost anyone in the digital entreprenurial or high-tech community about models for Australia to follow and Israel is invariably the first example brought up. In 1993 the Israeli government set up the Yozma venture capital fund which has managed $220m since inception. The country has the highest spend on R&D than any other OECD nation. Israel’s success can be mirrored in Australia. What is required here like ‘Silicon Israel’ is a combination of factors including investment in education on digital/technological business, access to engineers of high-tech, an adjustment of risk appetite (failure is as likely as success) and a public political agenda.

    The latter in the form of the creation of a ministerial portfolio of Digital/High Tech would be a significant step forward, providing public emphasis and amplification to an under served industry. In the meantime the community will no doubt continue to thrive in the grass roots pockets of inner-city centres only to flee Australian shores for greener capital pastures.

     

  • Just Seriously Good Insights into Strategies for the TMT Industry

    Just Seriously Good Insights into Strategies for the TMT Industry

    Welcome!

    ‘Oh no – not another part-time blog by a digital savvy management consultant…’ is what you may be thinking… But I promise you that Strategy4TelcoMediaTech will be anything but.

    Strategy4TelcoMediaTech aims to present my views as an experienced consultant working in an industry I am passionate about.  It will focus on the Australian market and changes globally that are likely to have an impact on the telecommunications, media or the high tech industry in Australia. More specifically this blog will provide a perspective on the strategies and business model innovations that are shaping the companies and organisations that play in this space and how to effectively execute these.

    I invite you to share, comment on, criticise and engage in rigorous debate on the views on this blog.

    My only hope is that my blogging speed keeps up with the industry!

    Twitter: @PeteCorbett

    LinkedIn: Peter Corbett